Evelina Medina, a former principal at Robert C. Dodson School in Yonkers, New York, became the subject of a controversial workplace sexual harassment lawsuit filed by Gisselle Vasquez, a Spanish-speaking school employee who alleged that her supervisor subjected her to inappropriate sexual demands and humiliating behavior.
The allegations included claims that Medina instructed Vasquez to take and store sexually explicit photographs, purchase lingerie, arrange a hotel room for a private meeting, and participate in conversations about her personal sexual relationships.
Vasquez also alleged that Medina physically grabbed her by the neck while demonstrating sexual behavior. The complaint further described inappropriate conduct by other school administrators.
The allegations attracted national attention in June 2021 after media reports detailed the lawsuit and highlighted the unusual circumstances involving a school principal and a subordinate employee.
However, the legal outcome requires careful distinction. Vasquez voluntarily dismissed her claims against Medina with prejudice in March 2024. Her remaining federal retaliation claims against the Yonkers Public School District and its superintendent were dismissed, and the Second Circuit affirmed that judgment in March 2025.
Who Is Evelina Medina?
Evelina Medina is a former school principal in Yonkers, Westchester County, New York. She served as principal of Robert C. Dodson School, a public school providing education from prekindergarten through eighth grade.
Medina became publicly known after Gisselle Vasquez filed a federal lawsuit alleging sexual harassment and inappropriate conduct during her employment at the school.
According to the lawsuit, Medina used her position of authority to make sexually inappropriate requests and involve Vasquez in personal matters involving Medina's romantic relationship.
The allegations were particularly serious because Medina was a senior school administrator responsible for supervising employees and maintaining a professional educational environment.
Medina's public profile is primarily associated with the Yonkers litigation. Reliable public information about her education, subsequent employment, and personal life is limited.
Who Is Gisselle Vasquez?
Gisselle Vasquez was employed by Yonkers Public Schools as a Spanish-speaking clerk at Robert C. Dodson School.
She began working for the school district in September 2013 as a school aide. In April 2016, she was promoted to Clerk I-Spanish Speaking and assigned to Dodson School.
Her responsibilities included administrative and clerical duties, with additional Spanish-language communication and translation responsibilities.
Vasquez was 35 years old when the allegations became public in 2021. She described herself as a single mother and explained that she worried about the professional consequences of refusing Medina's requests.
Her lawsuit alleged that the behavior created an uncomfortable working environment and placed her in an increasingly difficult position because Medina was her supervisor.
What Did Evelina Medina Allegedly Ask Gisselle Vasquez to Do?
The lawsuit described a series of incidents beginning in 2018. Vasquez alleged that Medina repeatedly involved her in personal sexual matters and used her position of authority to make inappropriate requests.
Requests to Take and Store Explicit Photographs
One of the central allegations concerned photographs Medina allegedly wanted Vasquez to take and store on her personal mobile phone.
According to the complaint, Medina first sent Vasquez a photograph of a man lying in bed wearing underwear and instructed her to save it.
The following day, Medina allegedly directed Vasquez to photograph her posing in underwear. Vasquez said she was uncomfortable with the request and questioned why her supervisor would involve her in such personal activities.
The lawsuit also alleged that Medina subsequently sent another sexually explicit photograph involving the man she described as her lover and instructed Vasquez to keep it on her phone.
Vasquez told the New York Post that she worried about the consequences of refusing because she depended on her employment and had a child to support.
Allegations Involving Lingerie and a Hotel Reservation
Another allegation involved Medina's requests for Vasquez to purchase lingerie on her behalf.
According to the lawsuit, Medina also directed Vasquez to arrange a hotel room in Yonkers using Vasquez's personal credit card. The room was allegedly intended for a private meeting between Medina and her boyfriend.
These allegations formed part of Vasquez's broader claim that Medina had crossed professional boundaries and used her subordinate employee to facilitate her personal relationship.
Alleged Physical Conduct
Vasquez also accused Medina of physically grabbing her by the neck and throat while demonstrating sexual movements that she allegedly wanted to perform with her boyfriend.
The complaint described this incident as another example of inappropriate behavior that made Vasquez uncomfortable in the workplace.
These accounts were allegations presented in the civil lawsuit, rather than findings established through a trial judgment against Medina.
Was Evelina Medina the Only School Administrator Accused?
No. Vasquez's lawsuit also identified other school administrators, including assistant principals Christopher Cassano and Sandra Guzman.
Vasquez alleged that Cassano engaged in inappropriate behavior, including asking sexually explicit questions and attempting to kiss her without consent.
She also alleged that Guzman made inappropriate personal comments and asked questions about her sexual activities.
These allegations formed part of the broader workplace harassment complaint involving multiple school officials.
However, the claims against Cassano and Guzman were dismissed by the district court in January 2022. Their dismissal should be distinguished from the later proceedings involving the school district and its superintendent.
How the Yonkers School Sexual Harassment Case Became Public
The allegations received widespread attention in June 2021 after Vasquez filed a federal lawsuit in the Southern District of New York.
Daily Voice published a report on June 9, 2021, describing the allegations involving photographs, lingerie, and the alleged hotel reservation.
News 12 Long Island also reported on the case, identifying Vasquez as a Spanish-speaking school secretary who accused her former principal of sexual harassment.
The story attracted attention because it involved allegations of misconduct by senior educational administrators in a public school environment.
Vasquez explained that she had not expected her supervisor to make such requests and that she felt uncomfortable about the situation.
The Yonkers School District declined to discuss the allegations publicly, stating that the matter was being handled by its legal team.
Gisselle Vasquez Filed a Federal Lawsuit in 2021
Vasquez filed her complaint on May 24, 2021, in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The case was titled Vasquez v. City of Yonkers et al., docket number 7:2021cv04620.
The original defendants included the Yonkers Public School District, the City of Yonkers, school administrators, and other individuals connected with the alleged workplace misconduct.
The complaint included allegations of sexual harassment and retaliation, with Vasquez arguing that the school district had failed to adequately address her concerns.
During the proceedings, the court narrowed the claims through several dismissal orders. By 2024, the remaining issues primarily concerned allegations of retaliation against the school district and Superintendent Edwin M. Quezada.
What Happened to Evelina Medina?
Medina was no longer employed by Yonkers Public Schools by the time the federal court proceedings reached their later stages.
The court's March 29, 2024 opinion confirmed that Medina had resigned from her employment with the district effective August 2019.
On March 14, 2024, Vasquez submitted a request to voluntarily dismiss her remaining claims against Medina with prejudice. The court approved that request the following day.
A dismissal with prejudice generally means that the dismissed claims cannot simply be brought again in a new lawsuit.
Importantly, the dismissal was voluntary. It was not a judicial finding following a trial that Medina had either committed or not committed the alleged conduct.
Therefore, the allegations should continue to be described as allegations rather than proven criminal or civil liability.
Why Did the Court Dismiss the Remaining Lawsuit?
On March 29, 2024, Magistrate Judge Victoria Reznik granted summary judgment in favor of the Yonkers Public School District and Superintendent Edwin M. Quezada.
The remaining lawsuit focused on whether Vasquez had experienced unlawful retaliation after filing a Title IX complaint concerning alleged sexual harassment by an assistant principal.
The court examined whether the school district or superintendent had taken an adverse employment action against her because she reported the misconduct.
The court noted several important circumstances:
- The superintendent transferred the employee accused of attempting to kiss Vasquez to another school shortly after her complaint.
- The school district initiated a Title IX investigation.
- The investigation ultimately determined that her initial complaint was substantiated.
- Vasquez requested a transfer to another school, and the superintendent approved it.
- Her salary, benefits, and employment classification remained unchanged following the transfer.
The court concluded that Vasquez had not established the necessary elements of her remaining retaliation and municipal-liability claims against the defendants.
The decision did not determine whether every alleged incident involving Medina had occurred. Those allegations were not resolved through a trial on their merits.
Second Circuit Court of Appeals Upholds the Decision in 2025
Vasquez appealed the district court's judgment to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
On March 24, 2025, the appellate court issued a summary order affirming the lower court's decision.
The appeal focused on whether the school district's failure to investigate additional allegations and the alleged circulation of information about Vasquez's complaint constituted unlawful retaliation.
The Second Circuit concluded that the evidence did not establish an adverse employment action attributable to the superintendent or the school district under the legal standard applicable to the case.
The appellate judges also rejected the argument that the superintendent's alleged conduct constituted an official district policy that would make the school district liable under Section 1983.
Consequently, the district court's judgment in favor of the school district and superintendent was affirmed.
Why the Case Matters for Workplace Harassment in Schools
The Yonkers case highlights the importance of professional boundaries, workplace reporting systems, and the responsibilities of administrators in public educational institutions.
School principals exercise significant authority over employees, including work assignments, supervision, and professional evaluations. That authority makes appropriate workplace conduct particularly important.
The allegations also demonstrate why employees need reliable channels to report inappropriate behavior without fearing professional consequences.
Although the final federal judgment did not establish liability against the school district or superintendent, the case generated important public discussion about the handling of sexual harassment complaints in educational workplaces.
Conclusion
Evelina Medina became the subject of public attention in 2021 after Gisselle Vasquez accused the former Yonkers school principal of sexual harassment and coercive workplace behavior.
The allegations included requests involving explicit photographs, lingerie purchases, hotel reservations, and inappropriate physical conduct. Vasquez also accused other school administrators of sexual harassment.
Medina resigned from Yonkers Public Schools in August 2019. Vasquez voluntarily dismissed her claims against Medina with prejudice in March 2024, without a trial resolving the underlying allegations.
The remaining retaliation lawsuit against the Yonkers Public School District and its superintendent was dismissed in March 2024, and the Second Circuit upheld that decision on March 24, 2025.
The case remains a notable example of the challenges involved in reporting workplace sexual harassment, particularly when the accused person occupies a senior position within an educational institution.
- Log in to post comments