The Discovery: A Gruesome Scene

Police responded to a welfare check requested by Donohue’s son, who grew concerned after not hearing from his father. Upon arrival at the marina around 10:43 PM, officers discovered Donohue’s lifeless body on his houseboat. Investigators revealed that he had been stabbed dozens of times in the head and chest, with such force that the knife blade snapped off inside his skull. His body was reportedly wrapped in a rug and blanket, bound with duct tape, and weighed down with hand weights—suggesting an attempt to conceal the crime.
Adding to the tragedy, one of Donohue’s dogs was found dead in the water nearby, though the circumstances of the animal’s death remain unclear. Divers later recovered remnants of the murder weapon in the harbor.

Suspect: Nora Nelson’s Troubled Past

Nora Nelson, a 24-year-old Boston resident originally from Tennessee, was arrested at the scene on unrelated warrants, including charges of assault, property destruction, and threatening behavior dating back to 2023. On Thursday, February 6, she was formally charged with Donohue’s murder after prosecutors obtained an arrest warrant.

• Key details about Nelson’s background include:
  A history of violent disputes, including an alleged assault on her ex-boyfriend, whom she reportedly owed $300,000.
• Prior arrests for assault with a deadly weapon (a television remote) and resisting arrest in Texas.
• A computer science degree from the University of Maryland, as disclosed by her attorney.

Nelson is currently held on $7,500 bail for the unrelated charges and is scheduled for arraignment on the murder charge on Friday, February 7.

Victim: A Beloved Attorney and Community Member

Joseph Donohue, a divorced father of three, was a respected attorney with nearly 40 years of experience in state and federal courts. His family described him as a “cherished friend” and “trusted colleague” who dedicated his life to helping others.
Marina residents expressed shock at his violent death, recalling him as “friendly” and “well-spoken.” One neighbor questioned Nelson’s presence at the scene, asking, “What would she be doing out here with an older attorney?”

Investigation: Unanswered Questions

While Nelson has been charged, many details remain shrouded in mystery:

• Motive: Authorities have not disclosed a possible connection between Nelson and Donohue.
• Timeline: Investigators are reviewing surveillance footage and financial records to trace Nelson’s movements before and after the crime.
• Dog’s Death: The role of Donohue’s deceased dog in the case is still under investigation.

The Boston Police Homicide Unit continues to urge anyone with information to contact them at 617-343-4470 or submit tips anonymously via CrimeStoppers.

Community Impact

The killing has rattled Charlestown’s tight-knit boating community, marking Boston’s fourth homicide of 2025. Residents described a heavy police presence on the night of the incident, with officers cordoning off the marina and advising bystanders to stay indoors.

Conclusion

As Nora Nelson faces murder charges, the case raises troubling questions about violence and motive. For Donohue’s family and friends, the focus remains on seeking justice for a man whose life was cut short in an act of brutal violence.
Updates to follow as the investigation progresses. For anonymous tips, contact Boston CrimeStoppers at 1-800-494-TIPS.